THE 80TH ACADEMY AWARDS
THE 80TH ACADEMY AWARDS
Editor and screenwriter Sean Paul Murphy throws a fun Oscar party every year, and if I can, I try to make it to his house for the festivities—and his Oscar pool. He’s been doing it for years, and two years ago I won the Oscar pool—(it helps pay for gas for the week!) –last year I came in second. Alas, I came in second again this year—horribly wrong with my guesses for sound and special effects wins. Here are my picks, with the winners, and a few observations.
BEST ACTOR (Leading Role)
My pick: Daniel Day-Lewis Winner: Daniel Day-Lewis
In hindsight, not one American actor won an acting award, giving the show quite the international flavor this year. I don’t think that the Irish Day-Lewis winning best actor was a surprise to anyone. One of the strongest, fiercest, performances in film, ever.
BEST ACTOR (Supporting)
My pick: Javier Bardem Winner: Javier Bardem
Bardem, with is wonderful performance in No Country For Old Men, makes Oscar history as he is the first Spaniard to win in an acting category.
BEST ACTRESS (Leading Role)
My pick: Julie Christie Winner: Marion Cotillard
Christie has long been a favorite of mine, but 32 year-old Cotillard has been collecting awards for years now in her native France, and recently won a BAFTA for La Vie en Rose. This is a film I’m looking forward to owning, and a performance I’m looking forward to watching again and again.
BEST ACTRESS (Supporting):
My pick: Cate Blanchett Winner: Tilda Swinton.
A surprise. Good performance and some interesting choices made by Brit Tilda Swinton in Michael Clayton, but an Oscar? A great actress, but I think she’s as surprised as we are.
ANIMATED (feature):
My pick: “Ratatouille” Winner: “Ratatouille”
Brad Bird is an incredible director, and his film The Iron Giant is one of my favorite animated films of recent years–and one of the guests actually brought ratatouille to our Oscar party, in honor of this wonderful film-mmmm good!
ART DIRECTION:
My pick: “Sweeney Todd” Winner: “Sweeney Todd”
Dante Ferretti is a master, and Sweeney Todd is a masterpiece of production design. I think that this film’s stature will grow over the years. Beside Depp’s nomination for best actor, I think that Helena Bonham Carter deserved a nomination as well for her superb work.
CINEMATOGRAPHY:
My Pick: “The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford” Winner: Robert Elswit for “There Will Be Blood”.
I was disappointed, as I wanted Roger Deakins to win for “Jesse James”. This was tough to pick because Deakins also shot NO COUNTRY FOR OLD MEN. Both films lensed by Deakins are simply beautiful.
COSTUME DESIGN:
My pick: “Sweeney Todd” Winner: “Elizabeth: The Golden Age”
DIRECTING:
My pick: Joel Coen and Ethan Coen Winner: The Coen Brothers
Never any doubt in my mind they would win.
DOCUMENTARY (feature):
My pick: “No End in Sight” Winner: “Taxi To The Dark Side”
DOCUMENTARY (short):
My pick: “Sari’s Mother” Winner: “Freeheld”
I was way off this year in the doc category!
FILM EDITING:
My pick: “The Bourne Ultimatum” Winner: “The Bourne Ultimatum”
The film with the most cuts wins!
FOREIGN LANGUAGE FILM:
My pick: “The Counterfeiters” (Austria) Winner: The Counterfeiters”
MAKE-UP:
My pick: “La Vie en Rose” Winner: “La Vie en Rose”
Really amazing work—but then so is the work done for Norbit—and I’m not kidding. The Eddie Murphy bashing is old and tiresome.
MUSIC (original score):
My pick: “Atonement” Winner: “Atonement”
MUSIC (original song):
My pick: “Falling Slowly” (from “Once”) Winner: “Falling Slowly”
BEST PICTURE:
My pick: “No Country for Old Men” Winner: “No Country For Old Men”
From dark to darker: The Departed wins best pic last year, and into a blacker hell with No Country…next year should be interesting…
SHORT FILM (animated):
My pick: “I Met The Walrus” Winner: “Peter and the Wolf”
I guess I’m a sucker for the Beatles, but Peter and the Wolf is a wonderful stop-motion animated film—and you can watch it on YouTube—until they remove it—because it deservedly won the Oscar!
SHORT FILM: (live action):
My pick: “Tanghi Argentini” Winner: “Le Mozart des Pickpockets”
I should have known–cute kids always win!
SOUND EDITING:
My pick: “Transformers” Winner: “The Bourne Ultimatum”
SOUND MIXING:
My pick: “Transformers” Winner: “The Bourne Ultimatum”
VISUAL EFFECTS:
My pick: “Transformers” Winner: “The Golden Compass”
I should have known–cute polar bears win! This is where I really fell off track with the Oscar guessing game. Somehow it makes sense that Bourne would win sound effects, but I really think “Transformers” is some incredible work, and will be judged in the future as a landmark in FX artistry and animation
SCREENPLAY (adapted):
My pick: “No Country for Old Men”, Joel Coen and Ethan Coen Winner: “No Country For Old Men”
SCREENPLAY (original):
My pick: “Juno”, Diablo Cody Winner: Diablo Cody, “Juno”
As far as the big show itself went, I loved the little animated opening of Governor Arnold driving the van loaded with Oscar statuettes to the Kodak Theater. A fun game of “spot the actor/character” as he made his way from the Hollywood sign to the event. Bill Conti again conducted the orchestra, and the overall mood of the show was subdued and rather quiet, and the whole evening, despite the jokes about its historic length, moved rather quickly. No big show numbers or glitz. It’s very clear that all of the montages were created in the event that the writer’s strike was still happening. Most of them were rather lame and uninspiring. The montage of past Oscar winners had zero magic, and acknowledge the weakness of the montage sequences, host Jon Stewart trotted out a couple of “gag” montages, making fun of the whole thing. Speaking of Stewart, he’s an amiable enough host, and his opening monologue rather good. But he’s not the “Hollywood Insider” that some spectacular past hosts have been, like Bob Hope, Johnny Carson or Billy Crystal, and he seems too respectful and subdued. My personal favorite moment with Jon Stewart was when he marveled at the “new media”, saying that he was watching Lawrence of Arabia on his cell phone. A wonderfully sharp and sarcastic dig at the cinema’s dire future: in a little over a hundred years we’ve come from the peep show to back were we started—the peep show! That’s progress?! In other “what’s wrong with this picture, department”—when’s Johnny Depp gonna get some Oscar love? I hope that he starts racking ‘em up, and doesn’t get his with an “honorary Oscar” when he’s on life support. Shades of some of the other greats that have been slighted by Oscar, like Alfred Hitchcock and Charlie Chaplin.Take, for instance, production designer Robert Boyle, who did receive an honorary Oscar this year. A brilliant art director who was nominated four times through-out a stellar career. At 98, he gave a heartfelt thank-you speech, and all I could think was that it was just a shame that he had never won in the past for such wonderful designs for films like Fiddler On The Roof, North By Northwest and so many others.I was surprised that this year there wasn’t an Irving Thalberg Award given, nor was there a Jean Hersholt Humanitarian Award. Missing these moments helped to underscore the mood that the show was somewhat down-sized, and that the producers did the best they could with what time they had to prepare the show from the time the writer’s strike ended to Oscar night. The lack of these awards have nothing to do with time, but they were missed by me. All in all, no political speeches, no big upsets, no big surprises, no “controversy”—not a particularly memorable or entertaining show. Memorable only, perhaps, that with the exception of the film Juno, it was an awards year filled with films that examined the darkness in the human heart. And the Oscar goes to: There Will Be No Country Ratatouille Assassination Blood For Old Counterfeiters In Sight, Sweeney Clayton. That about sums it up, and that’s a title sure to tongue-tie Cameron “cinematography” Diaz! Until next year!
© Mark Redfield





